No, you don't have anything that proves anyone lied. If he had forgotten making that commitment, then he wasn't lying when asked about it. And neither you nor I know whether he had or he hadn't.
Of course you're well aware of this, you're just pretending to be so breathtakingly stupid that you can't tell the difference between forgetting and lying.
"Elite - a small superior group; esp one that has a power out of proportion to its size." (Oxford English Dictionary)
The majority cannot therefore be the elite.
YOUR the only one being staggeringly stupid by insisting on an excuse that the man, sorry LIAR himself, hasnt used.
the evidence is there for all to see and your leaders response has never waylaid the charge.
he lied. deal with it fork boy.
if he asserts he forgot i'd consider it.
but as it stands all the evidence says enda kenny lied in the dail and mislead the house on the matter of making promises regarding roscomon.