Fine Gael: frontbench and top talent assessment

[cyberianpan]

who would you rate as the stars in FG ?

I'm suggesting these rating factors, 0 low 3 high:

Smart: well informed, intellectually curious, keen analytical feasibilities
Results: decisive, and can bring the people with them
Safe: not prone to rash decisions
Charm: charisma

Smart[COLOR="white"]___[/COLOR]Results[COLOR="white"]_____[/COLOR]Safe[COLOR="white"]____[/COLOR]Charm[COLOR="white"]____[/COLOR]Name
3[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Richard Bruton
0[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Simon Coveney
1[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Michael Creed
?[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Jimmy Deenihan
1[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Olwyn Enright
2[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Charles Flanagan
2[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 0[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Brian Hayes
3[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 0[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 0[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Phil Hogan
1[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 0[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Paul Kehoe
1[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Enda Kenny
2[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Olivia Mitchell
2[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Denis Naughten
3[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 3[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Fergus O'Dowd
3[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] James Reilly
1[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Michael Ring
3[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 0[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Alan Shatter
1[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Billy Timmins
3[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 1[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 3[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Leo Varadkar
1[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 0[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Frances Fitzgerald
2[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Michael Noonan
2[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 3[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Paschal Donohoe
3[COLOR="White"]____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] ?[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]___[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] 2[COLOR="White"]_____[COLOR="black"]|[/COLOR]____[/COLOR] Eugene Regan


Quote this post and rate 'em ! If this thread is popular, I might do the same for FF/Lab


cYp

[Iarmhi Gael]

If Carlsberg did low quality tabloid trash threads on a Forum - they'd employ you

[Supermanpolitician]

If Carlsberg did low quality tabloid trash threads on a Forum - they'd employ you

Have to agree.

When mods troll, they troll with class!

['orebel]

Can we do one for the Govt?

[hiding behind a poster]

If Carlsberg did low quality tabloid trash threads on a Forum - they'd employ you

Hear, Hear.

[Tomas Mor]

Why is this thread not locked , there was already another one on who will be on the FG front bench. And there are several on the FG heave also as has been pointed out by King Kane. Is there one law for some and another for others, How about it Dave.,

[EvotingMachine0197]

Terence Flanagan isn't on that last, and as things stand, I rate him higher than many on that list.

[cedarwood10]

Why wasn't there a category for the ability for hard graft?

[davewex]

it makes it a bit harder to pick a decent frontbench when have your top talent doesn't want you there!! but i like the thread

[CookieMonster]

cYp, what in God's name makes you think the front bench will be chosen on merit?