Register to Comment
Page 1076 of 1721 FirstFirst ... 7657697610261066107410751076107710781086112611761576 ... LastLast
Results 10,751 to 10,760 of 17206
Like Tree5411Likes
  1. #10751
    culmore culmore is offline

    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    3,406

    wemon say its their body so they are entitled to have full control over it, but they share it with a man and make life and then want to kill that life without the man having any say in it, thats murder to me and thats a serious crime no matter what the circumstances
    Sign in or Register Now to reply

  2. #10752
    talkingshop talkingshop is offline
    talkingshop's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    23,533

    Quote Originally Posted by petaljam View Post
    Even if you were correct in that, the point remains that his argument certainly holds true with respect to removing any human rights from the pregnant woman based on mere potentiality.

    Whether it breaks down when applied as an absolute is a separate issue, and not one I'm interested in getting into here, as it's irrelevant to my opinion on the subject of this thread, namely abortion.
    If you're not interested in it, that's fine, but with respect you don't get to control what people discuss on the thread! And the discussion I was having with this poster was very much on the thread topic. He came on here claiming to have an irrefutable argument to show abortion is ethnically permissible on the grounds of the moral status of the foetus (leaving aside the question of the rights of the mother), in fact he lectured people at length on it, so I'm perfectly entitled to engage with him on it.
    Last edited by talkingshop; 17th February 2017 at 05:28 PM.
    Sign in or Register Now to reply

  3. #10753
    petaljam petaljam is offline
    petaljam's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Posts
    23,032

    Quote Originally Posted by talkingshop View Post
    If you're not interested in it, that's fine, but with respect you don't get to control what people discuss on the thread! And the discussion I was having with this poster was very much on the thread topic. He came on here claiming to have an irrefutable argument to show abortion is ethnically permissible on the grounds of the moral status of the foetus (leaving aside the question of the rights of the mother), in fact he lectured people at length on it, so I'm perfectly entitled to engage with him on it.
    Gosh I wasn't telling you not to discuss it with anyone else, I've no idea why you would even imagine that.
    Just saying I wasn't saying whether you or he were right, and wasn't interested in that aspect.
    In case your reply to me picked up on that, instead of what I was actually saying.

    Which you've managed to do anyway. Thus proving my suspicions correct, of course.

    So. Any chance you might reply to my point, rather than attempt to discuss his with me?
    Sign in or Register Now to reply

  4. #10754
    talkingshop talkingshop is offline
    talkingshop's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    23,533

    Quote Originally Posted by petaljam View Post
    Gosh I wasn't telling you not to discuss it with anyone else, I've no idea why you would even imagine that.
    Just saying I wasn't saying whether you or he were right, and wasn't interested in that aspect.
    In case your reply to me picked up on that, instead of what I was actually saying.

    Which you've managed to do anyway. Thus proving my suspicions correct, of course.

    So. Any chance you might reply to my point, rather than attempt to discuss his with me?
    You know I think the "equal right to life" in the Irish Constitution is a nonsense, which goes beyond abortion. And I agree that no one really thinks the foetus has an equal right to life with the mother - all the pro-lifers really think that the mother has a greater right to life.

    I'm not sure where that gets us though on the matter of abortion as a matter of choice. I suspect the pro-life side would be quite happy with a new amendment to replace the 8th which got rid of the "equal right to life", but replaced it with "The Oireachtas shall not legislate for abortion except...." in very narrow circumstances.
    Sign in or Register Now to reply

  5. #10755
    Sailor Sailor is offline

    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Posts
    57,529

    Quote Originally Posted by talkingshop View Post
    You know I think the "equal right to life" in the Irish Constitution is a nonsense, which goes beyond abortion. And I agree that no one really thinks the foetus has an equal right to life with the mother - all the pro-lifers really think that the mother has a greater right to life.

    I'm not sure where that gets us though on the matter of abortion as a matter of choice. I suspect the pro-life side would be quite happy with a new amendment to replace the 8th which got rid of the "equal right to life", but replaced it with "The Oireachtas shall not legislate for abortion except...." in very narrow circumstances.
    The "equal right to life" is a bit of a red herring. The question to be answered, particularly by the pro-choice side, concerns how we are to regard the right to life of the unborn in comparison with lesser rights of the mother.
    Sign in or Register Now to reply

  6. #10756
    petaljam petaljam is offline
    petaljam's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Posts
    23,032

    Quote Originally Posted by Sailor View Post
    The "equal right to life" is a bit of a red herring. The question to be answered, particularly by the pro-choice side, concerns how we are to regard the right to life of the unborn in comparison with lesser rights of the mother.
    Only if you can prove why it should have any rights over her body at all. Equal rights would have some logic, although indefensible in practice. "A bit of rights" (i.e. when it suits you) has none. It just looks like a handy way of paying lip service to the "right to life of the unborn" while not doing anything of the sort, except very occasionally to some particularly vulnerable woman to save face.
    Sign in or Register Now to reply

  7. #10757
    talkingshop talkingshop is offline
    talkingshop's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    23,533

    Quote Originally Posted by petaljam View Post
    Only if you can prove why it should have any rights over her body at all. Equal rights would have some logic, although indefensible in practice. "A bit of rights" (i.e. when it suits you) has none. It just looks like a handy way of paying lip service to the "right to life of the unborn" while not doing anything of the sort, except very occasionally to some particularly vulnerable woman to save face.
    Well I think the pro-life argument is very clear here - the unborn is human and has a right to life, unless the mother's life is threatened.
    Sign in or Register Now to reply

  8. #10758
    Lumpy Talbot Lumpy Talbot is offline

    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    15,699
    Twitter
    @

    Quote Originally Posted by talkingshop View Post
    Well I think the pro-life argument is very clear here - the unborn is human and has a right to life, unless the mother's life is threatened.
    Well that is an advance on the attitude twenty years or so ago which was more of 'never mind the bitch- save the babbeh'. Progress of sorts.
    Sign in or Register Now to reply

  9. #10759
    Lumpy Talbot Lumpy Talbot is offline

    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    15,699
    Twitter
    @

    Quote Originally Posted by talkingshop View Post
    You know I think the "equal right to life" in the Irish Constitution is a nonsense, which goes beyond abortion. And I agree that no one really thinks the foetus has an equal right to life with the mother - all the pro-lifers really think that the mother has a greater right to life.

    I'm not sure where that gets us though on the matter of abortion as a matter of choice. I suspect the pro-life side would be quite happy with a new amendment to replace the 8th which got rid of the "equal right to life", but replaced it with "The Oireachtas shall not legislate for abortion except...." in very narrow circumstances.
    Problem there is very few people in a situation where they want to terminate for whatever reason are ever going to be concerned about what the Oireachtas thinks on the matter.

    It is a false debate. Abortion on demand already exist. It is just that the Irish state, not at all unusually, doesn't know what to do about it. So it carries on debating a matter that in 99% cases isn't even taking any notice of it.
    Sign in or Register Now to reply

  10. #10760
    The Eagle of the Ninth The Eagle of the Ninth is offline

    Join Date
    Oct 2013
    Posts
    58,570

    Quote Originally Posted by Lumpy Talbot View Post
    Problem there is very few people in a situation where they want to terminate for whatever reason are ever going to be concerned about what the Oireachtas thinks on the matter.

    It is a false debate. Abortion on demand already exist. It is just that the Irish state, not at all unusually, doesn't know what to do about it. So it carries on debating a matter that in 99% cases isn't even taking any notice of it.
    All discussion around abortion on Pie (and other Big Pies in Ireland) remind me of a famous Nichols and May sketch from the early 60s.

    He: Its a moral issue, goddammit -
    She: Oh yes, a moral issue -
    He: A goddam moral issue!
    She: And I do so prefer a moral issue to a real issue...

    Calc must be steaming he was finally escorted out the door from this thread
    Sign in or Register Now to reply

Sign in to CommentRegister to Comment