You do make some interesting points. It's true that charity shouldn't be an alternative to properly funded public services. It's also true that people can indulge in public acts of (false) charity for their own reward and recognition. I still think charity is important though. It's an expression of love and concern for others and often helps to raise awareness and sometimes shame government (and inter-governmental) bodies into doing more.

__________________
La mujer más oscura puede mover montañas si lo quiere.