View Single Post
  #103 (permalink)  
Old 26th April 2009
wombat wombat is offline
Politics.ie Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 5,368
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by riven View Post
Dave M I agree but my arguements are more fundamental.

I am simply cosidering the energy balance of the process. ...

Right now Ireland needs to begin its alternative energy infastructure. Just building the alternative sources would be a start and that is what Ireland must concentrate one now.
More efficient means for PSH are being investigated as well as improved batteries or
If the question were simply one of efficiency, we would build a nuclear station or a series of gas fired stations. Since the former is not possible and the latter would increase our dependence on imported gas we are left with developing windpower to as large a scale as possible. In the context of having too much power when we don't need it and not enough when we do, pumped storage has to be considered as part of the mix and as such, it should be considered as part of the cost of large scale use of renewables. Again, the basic question is do we have sites which are suitable for pumped storage? Long before energy became a subject of popular discussion, the ESB investigated possible sites for hydro stations and pumped storage as part of their diversification program.
Reply With Quote